Since its opening in June, Lefty’s Righteous Bagels quickly became a neighborhood favorite. Its cheerful vibe, mustard-yellow and wood-brown interior and natural light from its windowed storefront make you feel right at home. The staff welcomes regular customers by name.
One loyal customer is Carol Johnson, who travels four stops on the El from Wilmette once a week for a garlic onion bagel.
“Their bagels are great. Their coffee is excellent. It’s just a nice group of people,” Johnson said.
Lefty’s is serious about its bagels, keeping them crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside. Its branded tissue boxes, placed around the shop, remind you that the mess is worth it, but wiping your hands is righteous.
Its menu keeps the wordplay going with sandwich items named after what they say are “some of the most righteous characters around.” Spread options range from Jalapeño to Kerrygold Butter to Garlic confit to keep your bagel as customizable as can be.
With its unbeatable breakfast and lunch offerings, it’s no surprise Lefty’s Righteous Bagels was titled Best New Business in Evanston. It only takes one visit, and your bagel made just right, to leave you craving for more after the first bite.
